eBikeMetric
eBikeMetric

How to Choose an E-Bike for a Hilly Commute

GuidePublished

We don't ride these bikes. Specs come from our database, converted to the same units. How we research them

For a commute with hills, start with the route: where the climbs are, where you have to stop and start again on a slope, what you carry and whether you can charge before the ride home. Then compare motor type, claimed motor torque, battery capacity, weight and listed payload for each bike you're considering, keeping in mind that these are manufacturer claims. A higher torque figure doesn't prove a bike will climb your hill better. Without a climbing test under the same conditions, use the comparison to decide which bikes to test, and ride them on your hill if you can. We haven't tested the bikes in this guide.

If your ride to work includes a real climb, the spec sheet only gets you part of the way. This guide covers how to map the hills on your route, what a torque claim can and can't tell you, where motor type fits in and four bikes to compare without a ranking. Then it looks at the battery you need for the climb home and how to test a bike on your own hill. For choosing a commuter e-bike in general, start with best commuter e-bikes.

Map the hills on your commute

Before you look at motors, write down what your hills actually ask of a bike. The same climb is a different job on a fresh morning ride than at the end of the day with a loaded bag and a battery that's already partly used.

  • Which way you climb. Is the hill on the way to work, on the way home, or both? A climb near the end of the ride home comes when the battery has the least charge left.
  • Stops on the slope. Do you have to stop at a light or a sign partway up and pull away again? Starting from a stop on a hill is a different test from rolling into the climb.
  • What you carry. A laptop, a change of clothes or groceries add weight on every climb. Note what you carry on a typical day.
  • Charging before the ride home. Cyclingnews notes that charging means “having a handy power outlet close by where you park your bike, either at home or at work.” Find out whether you can charge at work before you count on it.
  • The way down. Every climb on a commute is a descent in the other direction. Note the steep downhill stretches too, because you'll be braking there with the same load.
  • Your fallback. If the battery runs low before the top, how would you get yourself and the bike home?

This is a checklist for your route, not a grade or distance limit. We don't set a general threshold for how steep is too steep, because the answer depends on the rider, the load and the bike.

What a torque claim can and can't tell you

Spec sheets list claimed motor torque in newton-meters (Nm). It's the manufacturer's figure for the motor's output, and it's useful for seeing how a bike is configured. It isn't a climbing result. A torque figure on its own doesn't tell you how a bike will handle your hill with your load, and a lower figure doesn't show that a bike climbs worse. Claimed motor torque is also a different thing from a torque sensor, which reads how hard you press on the pedals. Hub vs. mid-drive commuter e-bikes explains that difference.

To compare climbing, you'd need something our sources don't have for the bikes in this guide: each bike ridden up the same hill, with the same rider and load, in the same assist level, with speed and battery use recorded. Some reviewers do run hill tests. Electric Bike Report says “The bikes we test are put through a number of assessments, including hill climb, range, and braking tests.” Before you apply a result like that to your route, check that it covers the exact model and version you're considering, under conditions close to yours.

Check the motor layout for your route

Motor type is where the motor sits: in a wheel hub, or at the cranks on a mid-drive. Aventon sells its Level 4 commuter both ways. According to Aventon's comparison guide, the Level 4 ADV is the mid-drive version and the Level 4 REC uses a hub motor. Velotric's Discover 3 page lists the Discover M as a mid-drive. On a hilly route, motor type is one input to test, not an automatic answer. For how the two layouts differ in feel, sensors and upkeep, see hub vs. mid-drive commuter e-bikes.

Compare candidates without a torque ranking

Each of these four bikes has a manufacturer source for its motor type, or a manufacturer claim about commuting on slopes, and our catalog has the specs this comparison needs. They're candidates to check against your route, not a list of the best climbers, and we haven't ridden them. Rows are listed alphabetically by brand and model. They aren't ranked, and price and affiliate links play no part in which bikes appear or in what order.

Candidates for a hilly commute, listed alphabetically. Motor type comes from the manufacturer page linked in each cell. Torque, battery, weight and payload are manufacturer claims from our catalog, not test results, and none of them ranks climbing ability.

Claimed range is the manufacturer's figure for one charge, not your round trip over hills. A listed class can name several modes, not the class a bike ships in.

  • Bike

    Aventon Level 4 ADV

    Claimed range
    Up to 110 mi
    Listed class (modes)
    1, 2, 3
    Check on your hill
    It shares a frame with the REC, so ride both on the same climb if you can. Sensor type isn't verified in our sources
  • Bike

    Aventon Level 4 REC

    Claimed range
    Up to 75 mi
    Listed class (modes)
    2, 3
    Check on your hill
    Aventon lists it as “Sensor Switch Compatible (Cadence & Torque)”, so try both sensor modes on the climb
  • Bike

    Mokwheel Tarmac

    Claimed range
    Up to 60 mi
    Listed class (modes)
    3
    Check on your hill
    Mokwheel says it “can easily cope with urban slopes and loaded commuting.” That's the manufacturer's claim, not an independent test
  • Bike

    Velotric Discover M

    Claimed range
    Up to 95 mi
    Listed class (modes)
    1, 2, 3
    Check on your hill
    Velotric lists pre-installed fenders and a rear rack as standard. Sensor type isn't verified in our sources, so check it on Velotric's page

Listed payload is the weight limit the manufacturer gives. It tells you whether your load fits within that limit, not how the bike climbs while carrying it, so check on the manufacturer page what the limit covers. Any two bikes in the table also differ in more than one spec, so don't read a gap in the table as the effect of the motor alone.

Take your hill checklist to a test ride, or hold it up against a review that states its test conditions. Then open the product page of each bike you want to check and confirm the version and current specs. To browse more bikes, see e-bikes for hills in our catalog.

Account for the climb home

Hills, the load you carry and the assist level you ride in all affect how far a charge goes. That's why a claimed range can't stand in for what you'll actually get on your route. The two questions that matter are whether you can charge at work, and how much battery you'll have left before the last climb home.

To work out battery size for your own round trip, see how much battery you need for your commute.

Test the bike on your actual hill

  • Ride your steepest climb with a load like the one you usually carry.
  • Stop partway up and pull away again in the assist level you'd normally use.
  • Note the speed you can hold on the climb, and how much battery the display shows before and after.
  • Ride back down and check how the brakes and handling feel with that load.
  • Try each assist level, and each sensor mode if the bike has more than one, on the same stretch.
  • When you read a review, check whether it names the exact model and version, the hill, the rider and load, and the assist level. If it doesn't, treat the result as a general impression, not a prediction for your route.

If you can't ride a bike before you buy, ask about the return policy before you order, so a bike that struggles on your hill isn't a sunk cost.

Check class, cost and riding conditions

  • Class. Class is about how the assist works and where you're allowed to ride, not about climbing power. Check which mode you'll ride in and the rules on your route. E-bike classes explained covers what each class means.
  • Total cost. Add up what the bike doesn't include, such as lights, fenders, a rack, a lock and a second charger for work. See how much an e-bike costs.
  • Riding in the dark. If part of your hilly route is in the dark, check lights, tires and brakes before you buy. See e-bike commuting in the dark.

Frequently asked questions

Does more motor torque mean better hill climbing?

Not on its own. Claimed motor torque is the manufacturer's figure for the motor's output. It doesn't tell you how a bike handles your hill with your load, and our sources have no climbing test of these bikes under the same conditions. Use it to compare configurations, then test on your climb. See what a torque claim can and can't tell you.

Do I need a mid-drive for a hilly commute?

Not automatically. Motor type is one part of the decision, along with your route, your load and how the bike rides when you test it. If your route climbs, test both types if you can, and compare them in hub vs. mid-drive commuter e-bikes.

Will the advertised range cover my ride home?

You can't tell from the claimed range. It's the manufacturer's figure for one charge, and hills, load and assist level all change what you'll get. Check your round trip, your climbs and whether you can charge at work, then see how much battery you need for your commute.

Which e-bike class can I use on my route?

That depends on the rules where you ride. A bike that lists several classes offers modes, not all of them at once. Check which mode you'll ride in, and see e-bike classes explained.

Your next step

Map your hills, shortlist from the table, then test on your climb. Go through the route checklist, pick the bikes worth trying from the comparison, and ride them on your hill with your usual load. For parking, charging and equipment, finish your choice with best commuter e-bikes.